0.07/0.12 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.07/0.13 % Command : run_portfolio.sh /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p /export/starexec/sandbox/tmp/tmp.S09Z1wLO7U 0.13/0.34 % Computer : n026.cluster.edu 0.13/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.13/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.13/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.13/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.13/0.34 % CPULimit : 960 0.13/0.34 % DateTime : Thu Jul 2 08:31:39 EDT 2020 0.13/0.35 % CPUTime : 0.13/0.35 % Running portfolio for 120 s 0.13/0.35 % File : /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p 0.13/0.35 % Number of cores: 8 0.13/0.35 % Python version: Python 3.6.8 0.13/0.35 % Running in HO mode 0.43/0.61 % Estimated wc time : 1286 0.43/0.61 % Estimated cpu time (7 cpus) : 183.71428571428572 0.54/0.69 % /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/lams/s6.sh running for 21s 0.54/0.70 % /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/lams/new_b3.2.norw.sh running for 15s 0.54/0.72 % /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/lams/b.rpo.sh running for 21s 0.54/0.73 % /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/lams/s6.ds.sh running for 10s 0.54/0.73 % /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/lams/c.s.2.sh running for 68s 0.54/0.74 % /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/lams/c.easy.sh running for 26s 0.54/0.74 % /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/lams/old_b3.avatar.sh running for 15s 0.54/0.74 % /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/lams/old_sp2.sh running for 17s 0.55/0.79 % /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/lams/b.sh running for 31s 0.56/0.85 % Solved by lams/c.easy.sh. 0.56/0.85 % done 57 iterations in 0.091s 0.56/0.85 % SZS status Theorem for '/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p' 0.56/0.85 % SZS output start Refutation 0.56/0.85 tff(defD1, axiom, god() = 0.56/0.85 ^[X:mu]: 0.56/0.85 mforall_indset(^[Phi:((mu * $i) > $o)]: mimplies(positive(Phi),Phi(X)))). 0.56/0.85 tff(mforall_indset, axiom, mforall_indset() = 0.56/0.85 ^[Phi:(((mu * $i) > $o * $i) > $o),W]: (![X:((mu * $i) > $o)]: Phi(X,W))). 0.56/0.85 tff('0', plain, 0.56/0.85 mforall_indset = 0.56/0.85 (^[Phi:(((mu * $i) > $o * $i) > $o),W]: (![X:((mu * $i) > $o)]: Phi(X,W))), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], [mforall_indset])). 0.56/0.85 tff('1', plain, 0.56/0.85 mforall_indset = 0.56/0.85 (^[V_1:(((mu * $i) > $o * $i) > $o),V_2]: 0.56/0.85 (![X4:((mu * $i) > $o)]: V_1(X4,V_2))), 0.56/0.85 define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff(mimplies, axiom, mimplies() = 0.56/0.85 ^[Phi:(($i > $o)),Psi:(($i > $o)),W]: (Phi(W) => Psi(W))). 0.56/0.85 tff('2', plain, 0.56/0.85 mimplies = (^[Phi:(($i > $o)),Psi:(($i > $o)),W]: (Phi(W) => Psi(W))), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], [mimplies])). 0.56/0.85 tff('3', plain, 0.56/0.85 mimplies = 0.56/0.85 (^[V_1:(($i > $o)),V_2:(($i > $o)),V_3]: (V_1(V_3) => V_2(V_3))), 0.56/0.85 define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff('4', plain, 0.56/0.85 god = 0.56/0.85 (^[X:mu]: 0.56/0.85 mforall_indset(^[Phi:((mu * $i) > $o)]: mimplies(positive(Phi),Phi(X)))), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], [defD1, '1', '3'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('5', plain, 0.56/0.85 god = 0.56/0.85 (^[V_1:mu]: 0.56/0.85 mforall_indset(^[V_2:((mu * $i) > $o)]: 0.56/0.85 mimplies(positive(V_2),V_2(V_1)))), 0.56/0.85 define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff(mvalid, axiom, mvalid() = ^[Phi:(($i > $o))]: (![W]: Phi(W))). 0.56/0.85 tff('6', plain, mvalid = (^[Phi:(($i > $o))]: (![W]: Phi(W))), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], [mvalid])). 0.56/0.85 tff('7', plain, mvalid = (^[V_1:(($i > $o))]: (![X4]: V_1(X4))), 0.56/0.85 define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff(mbox, axiom, mbox() = mbox_generic(rel)). 0.56/0.85 tff(mbox_generic, axiom, mbox_generic() = 0.56/0.85 ^[R:(($i * $i) > $o),Phi:(($i > $o)),W]: (![V]: (Phi(V) | (~R(W,V))))). 0.56/0.85 tff('8', plain, 0.56/0.85 mbox_generic = 0.56/0.85 (^[R:(($i * $i) > $o),Phi:(($i > $o)),W]: (![V]: (Phi(V) | (~R(W,V))))), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], [mbox_generic])). 0.56/0.85 tff('9', plain, 0.56/0.85 mbox_generic = 0.56/0.85 (^[V_1:(($i * $i) > $o),V_2:(($i > $o)),V_3]: 0.56/0.85 (![X4]: (V_2(X4) | (~V_1(V_3,X4))))), 0.56/0.85 define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff('10', plain, mbox = mbox_generic(rel), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], [mbox, '9'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('11', plain, mbox = mbox_generic(rel), define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff(mexists_ind, axiom, mexists_ind() = 0.56/0.85 ^[Phi:((mu * $i) > $o),W]: (?[X:mu]: Phi(X,W))). 0.56/0.85 tff('12', plain, 0.56/0.85 mexists_ind = (^[Phi:((mu * $i) > $o),W]: (?[X:mu]: Phi(X,W))), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], [mexists_ind])). 0.56/0.85 tff('13', plain, 0.56/0.85 mexists_ind = (^[V_1:((mu * $i) > $o),V_2]: (?[X4:mu]: V_1(X4,V_2))), 0.56/0.85 define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff(thmT3, conjecture, (mvalid(mbox(mexists_ind(^[X:mu]: god(X)))))). 0.56/0.85 tff(zf_stmt_0, conjecture, 0.56/0.85 (![X4,X6]: 0.56/0.85 ((?[X8:mu]: (![X10:((mu * $i) > $o)]: (positive(X10,X6) => X10(X8,X6)))) | 0.56/0.85 (~rel(X4,X6))))). 0.56/0.85 tff(zf_stmt_1, negated_conjecture, 0.56/0.85 (~ 0.56/0.85 (![X4,X6]: 0.56/0.85 ((?[X8:mu]: 0.56/0.85 (![X10:((mu * $i) > $o)]: (positive(X10,X6) => X10(X8,X6)))) | 0.56/0.85 (~rel(X4,X6)))))). 0.56/0.85 tff('14', plain, ![X68 : mu]: positive(sk_X10(X68), sk_X6), 0.56/0.85 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 0.56/0.85 tff(mforall_ind, axiom, mforall_ind() = 0.56/0.85 ^[Phi:((mu * $i) > $o),W]: (![X:mu]: Phi(X,W))). 0.56/0.85 tff('15', plain, 0.56/0.85 mforall_ind = (^[Phi:((mu * $i) > $o),W]: (![X:mu]: Phi(X,W))), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], [mforall_ind])). 0.56/0.85 tff('16', plain, 0.56/0.85 mforall_ind = (^[V_1:((mu * $i) > $o),V_2]: (![X4:mu]: V_1(X4,V_2))), 0.56/0.85 define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff(thmT2, axiom, 0.56/0.85 (mvalid(mforall_ind(^[X:mu]: mimplies(god(X),essence(god,X)))))). 0.56/0.85 tff(zf_stmt_2, axiom, 0.56/0.85 (![X4,X6:mu]: 0.56/0.85 ((![X8:((mu * $i) > $o)]: (positive(X8,X4) => X8(X6,X4))) => 0.56/0.85 essence(^[V_1:mu,V_2]: 0.56/0.85 (![X10:((mu * $i) > $o)]: (positive(X10,V_2) => X10(V_1,V_2))), 0.56/0.85 X6,X4)))). 0.56/0.85 tff('17', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X72 : mu, X73]: 0.56/0.85 ( essence( 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: (positive(Y2, Y1) => Y2(Y0, Y1)))))), 0.56/0.85 X72, X73) 0.56/0.85 | positive(sk_X8_1(X72, X73), X73)), 0.56/0.85 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_2])). 0.56/0.85 tff(mdia, axiom, mdia() = mdia_generic(rel)). 0.56/0.85 tff(mdia_generic, axiom, mdia_generic() = 0.56/0.85 ^[R:(($i * $i) > $o),Phi:(($i > $o)),W]: (?[V]: (Phi(V) & R(W,V)))). 0.56/0.85 tff('18', plain, 0.56/0.85 mdia_generic = 0.56/0.85 (^[R:(($i * $i) > $o),Phi:(($i > $o)),W]: (?[V]: (Phi(V) & R(W,V)))), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], [mdia_generic])). 0.56/0.85 tff('19', plain, 0.56/0.85 mdia_generic = 0.56/0.85 (^[V_1:(($i * $i) > $o),V_2:(($i > $o)),V_3]: 0.56/0.85 (?[X4]: (V_2(X4) & V_1(V_3,X4)))), 0.56/0.85 define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff('20', plain, mdia = mdia_generic(rel), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], [mdia, '19'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('21', plain, mdia = mdia_generic(rel), define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff(corC, axiom, (mvalid(mdia(mexists_ind(^[X:mu]: god(X)))))). 0.56/0.85 tff(zf_stmt_3, axiom, 0.56/0.85 (![X4]: 0.56/0.85 (?[X6]: 0.56/0.85 ((?[X8:mu]: 0.56/0.85 (![X10:((mu * $i) > $o)]: (positive(X10,X6) => X10(X8,X6)))) & 0.56/0.85 rel(X4,X6))))). 0.56/0.85 tff('22', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X70, X71 : (mu * $i) > $o]: 0.56/0.85 ( X71(sk_X8(X70), sk_X6_1(X70)) | ~ positive(X71, sk_X6_1(X70))), 0.56/0.85 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_3])). 0.56/0.85 tff('23', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X0, X1 : mu]: 0.56/0.85 ( essence( 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: (positive(Y2, Y1) => Y2(Y0, Y1)))))), 0.56/0.85 X1, sk_X6_1(X0)) 0.56/0.85 | sk_X8_1(X1, sk_X6_1(X0), sk_X8(X0), sk_X6_1(X0))), 0.56/0.85 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['17', '22'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('24', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X72 : mu, X73]: 0.56/0.85 ( essence( 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: (positive(Y2, Y1) => Y2(Y0, Y1)))))), 0.56/0.85 X72, X73) 0.56/0.85 | ~ sk_X8_1(X72, X73, X72, X73)), 0.56/0.85 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_2])). 0.56/0.85 tff('25', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X0]: 0.56/0.85 ( essence( 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: (positive(Y2, Y1) => Y2(Y0, Y1)))))), 0.56/0.85 sk_X8(X0), sk_X6_1(X0)) 0.56/0.85 | essence( 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: (positive(Y2, Y1) => Y2(Y0, Y1)))))), 0.56/0.85 sk_X8(X0), sk_X6_1(X0))), 0.56/0.85 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['23', '24'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('26', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X0]: 0.56/0.85 essence( 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: (positive(Y2, Y1) => Y2(Y0, Y1)))))), 0.56/0.85 sk_X8(X0), sk_X6_1(X0)), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify', [status(thm)], ['25'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('27', plain, ![X70]: rel(X70, sk_X6_1(X70)), 0.56/0.85 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_3])). 0.56/0.85 tff(msymmetric, axiom, msymmetric() = 0.56/0.85 ^[R:(($i * $i) > $o)]: (![S,T]: (R(S,T) => R(T,S)))). 0.56/0.85 tff('28', plain, 0.56/0.85 msymmetric = (^[R:(($i * $i) > $o)]: (![S,T]: (R(S,T) => R(T,S)))), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], [msymmetric])). 0.56/0.85 tff('29', plain, 0.56/0.85 msymmetric = 0.56/0.85 (^[V_1:(($i * $i) > $o)]: (![X4,X6]: (V_1(X4,X6) => V_1(X6,X4)))), 0.56/0.85 define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff(sym, axiom, (msymmetric(rel))). 0.56/0.85 tff(zf_stmt_4, axiom, (![X4,X6]: (rel(X4,X6) => rel(X6,X4)))). 0.56/0.85 tff('30', plain, ![X62, X63]: ( rel(X62, X63) | ~ rel(X63, X62)), 0.56/0.85 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_4])). 0.56/0.85 tff('31', plain, ![X0]: rel(sk_X6_1(X0), X0), 0.56/0.85 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['27', '30'])). 0.56/0.85 tff(defD3, axiom, necessary_existence() = 0.56/0.85 ^[X:mu]: 0.56/0.85 mforall_indset(^[Phi:((mu * $i) > $o)]: 0.56/0.85 mimplies(essence(Phi,X), 0.56/0.85 mbox(mexists_ind(^[Y:mu]: Phi(Y)))))). 0.56/0.85 tff('32', plain, 0.56/0.85 necessary_existence = 0.56/0.85 (^[X:mu]: 0.56/0.85 mforall_indset(^[Phi:((mu * $i) > $o)]: 0.56/0.85 mimplies(essence(Phi,X), 0.56/0.85 mbox(mexists_ind(^[Y:mu]: Phi(Y)))))), 0.56/0.85 inference('simplify_rw_rule', [status(thm)], 0.56/0.85 [defD3, '11', '9', '13', '1', '3'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('33', plain, 0.56/0.85 necessary_existence = 0.56/0.85 (^[V_1:mu]: 0.56/0.85 mforall_indset(^[V_2:((mu * $i) > $o)]: 0.56/0.85 mimplies(essence(V_2,V_1), 0.56/0.85 mbox(mexists_ind(^[V_3:mu]: V_2(V_3)))))), 0.56/0.85 define([status(thm)])). 0.56/0.85 tff(axA5, axiom, (mvalid(positive(necessary_existence)))). 0.56/0.85 tff(zf_stmt_5, axiom, 0.56/0.85 (![X4]: 0.56/0.85 positive(^[V_1:mu,V_2]: 0.56/0.85 (![X6:((mu * $i) > $o)]: 0.56/0.85 (essence(X6,V_1,V_2) => 0.56/0.85 (![X8]: ((~rel(V_2,X8)) | (?[X10:mu]: X6(X10,X8)))))), 0.56/0.85 X4))). 0.56/0.85 tff('34', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X69]: 0.56/0.85 positive( 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: 0.56/0.85 (essence(Y2, Y0, Y1) => 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y3 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 ((~(rel(Y1, Y3))) | (??((^[Y4 : mu]: Y2(Y4, Y3))))))))))))), 0.56/0.85 X69), 0.56/0.85 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_5])). 0.56/0.85 tff('35', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X70, X71 : (mu * $i) > $o]: 0.56/0.85 ( X71(sk_X8(X70), sk_X6_1(X70)) | ~ positive(X71, sk_X6_1(X70))), 0.56/0.85 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_3])). 0.56/0.85 tff('36', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X0]: 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: 0.56/0.85 (essence(Y2, Y0, Y1) => 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y3 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 ((~(rel(Y1, Y3))) | (??((^[Y4 : mu]: Y2(Y4, Y3)))))))))))))( 0.56/0.85 sk_X8(X0), sk_X6_1(X0)), 0.56/0.85 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['34', '35'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('37', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X0]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y0 : (mu * $i) > $o]: 0.56/0.85 (essence(Y0, sk_X8(X0), sk_X6_1(X0)) => 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 ((~(rel(sk_X6_1(X0), Y1))) | 0.56/0.85 (??((^[Y2 : mu]: Y0(Y2, Y1)))))))))))), 0.56/0.85 inference('ho_norm', [status(thm)], ['36'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('38', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X0 : (mu * $i) > $o, X1, X2]: 0.56/0.85 ( X0(sk_X8_3(X1, X0), X1) 0.56/0.85 | ~ rel(sk_X6_1(X2), X1) 0.56/0.85 | ~ essence(X0, sk_X8(X2), sk_X6_1(X2))), 0.56/0.85 inference('cnf_otf', [status(thm)], ['37'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('39', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X0, X1 : (mu * $i) > $o]: 0.56/0.85 (~ essence(X1, sk_X8(X0), sk_X6_1(X0)) | X1(sk_X8_3(X0, X1), X0)), 0.56/0.85 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['31', '38'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('40', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X0]: 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: (positive(Y2, Y1) => Y2(Y0, Y1))))))( 0.56/0.85 sk_X8_3(X0, 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: (positive(Y2, Y1) => Y2(Y0, Y1))))))), 0.56/0.85 X0), 0.56/0.85 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['26', '39'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('41', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X0]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y0 : (mu * $i) > $o]: 0.56/0.85 (positive(Y0, X0) => 0.56/0.85 Y0( 0.56/0.85 sk_X8_3(X0, 0.56/0.85 (^[Y1 : mu,Y2 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y3 : (mu * $i) > $o]: 0.56/0.85 (positive(Y3, Y2) => Y3(Y1, Y2))))))), X0))))), 0.56/0.85 inference('ho_norm', [status(thm)], ['40'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('42', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X0 : (mu * $i) > $o, X1]: 0.56/0.85 ( X0( 0.56/0.85 sk_X8_3(X1, 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: (positive(Y2, Y1) => Y2(Y0, Y1))))))), 0.56/0.85 X1) 0.56/0.85 | ~ positive(X0, X1)), 0.56/0.85 inference('cnf_otf', [status(thm)], ['41'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('43', plain, 0.56/0.85 ![X0 : mu]: 0.56/0.85 sk_X10(X0, 0.56/0.85 sk_X8_3(sk_X6, 0.56/0.85 (^[Y0 : mu,Y1 : $i]: 0.56/0.85 (!!((^[Y2 : (mu * $i) > $o]: (positive(Y2, Y1) => Y2(Y0, Y1))))))), 0.56/0.85 sk_X6), 0.56/0.85 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['14', '42'])). 0.56/0.85 tff('44', plain, ![X68 : mu]: ~ sk_X10(X68, X68, sk_X6), 0.56/0.85 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 0.56/0.85 tff('45', plain, $false, inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['43', '44'])). 0.56/0.85 0.56/0.85 % SZS output end Refutation 0.56/0.85 0.56/0.85 0.56/0.85 % Terminating... 0.61/0.95 % Runner terminated. 0.61/0.96 % Zipperpin 1.5 exiting 0.61/0.97 EOF